Archive for August, 2008



Wellington Treaty Settlement signed

August 19th, 2008

Just got back from the signing ceremony for the Taranaki Whanui (Port Nicholson Block) Settlement.  It was a cold old morning at Pipitea Marae, but a good natured and heartfelt event put that to the back of everyone’s mind. It was great to see a big turnout of local body politicians from across the region, as well as MPs, and representatives of community groups and others involved in the negotiations.

This settlement has set records for being the fastest to go from commencing negotiations to signing, and Dr Ngatata Love was keen for it to set a record for going through Parliament as well, though I think the election might well get in the way of that!

It is a far reaching settlement as I have said before, and will require significant on-going cooperation between central, local government and iwi to fulfil the commitments that have been made.   The islands of Wellington Harbour are returned to iwi, with rights of public access secure, and there are options on the purchase of a number of public buildings.  The settlement also includes a compensation package of $25 million.

An important component to this agreement is that in addition to the Crown apology, the Taranaki Whanui have issued their own statement of forgiveness in return.   The feeling on both sides is that this signals a fresh start for a healthy and long term relationship.

Congrats to those on all sides of the settlement.  It sounds like a monumental effort for all concerned.  Dr Cullen continues his remarkable pace of settlements.  I heard the other day that some hapu/iwi have even composed waiata and haka in his honour in light of recent achievements. It certainly has been a time of great progress in our nation’s journey to social justice.

The way we do politics: connecting to the community

August 14th, 2008

On a recent school visit a school a teacher told me that she was no longer going to take her class to see Parliament in action.  She felt that the behaviour that they witnessed undermined the values that she was trying to impart to them, in particular courtesy, tolerance and fairness.   On the campaign trail I also come across people who are disenchanted with the whole political process because of what they see as the self-serving behaviour of politicians.  This is a sad situation, and one that I think my generation of politicians need to do something to rectify.

I do not want to sound like a political ‘wowser’ in saying this.  Politics should be a robust contest where values, vision, ideas and policies are debated and challenged.  There will be heated discussions, as there are when people disagree.  From time to time we (me included) all say things that we shouldn’t, but that can and should be put right.

The most difficult area for me in this regard, as I have written about before is the question of character. What I do not think has a place are cheap shots and personal insults that are not aimed at winning an argument, but rather at undermining someone at a personal level.  The exchange between my National opponent and the Co-Leader of the Greens is illustrative in this regard.  Russel was talking about policy, when Stephen interjected with a comment on personalities, including invoking Rod Donald’s death.  Russel’s reply was ill-mannered and regretable, but the exchange should never have been started.

Overall though I think the key to restoring some faith in politics is to make people feel that it is something that is relevant to them and that they can engage with in a meaningful way.  To do this we need to bring our politics closer to our communities.

The best electorate MPs do this on a daily basis, assisting their constituents with all manner of problems and making a practical difference in their lives.  At other levels I think there are opportunities.  I think we need to investigate the use of Citizens Assemblies and Citizens Juries to discuss issues of significance and importance. These models bring randomly selected people together to consider a topic with all the advice on hand. 

I am also a fan of the Community Cabinet’s begun by the Queensland State Government and now being taken up with great gusto by Kevin Rudd’s government.  The Labour-led government here has gone some way down this path with the Community Forums, but the Australian example has the Cabinet holding meetings in regional and rural towns, having open and informal discussions as well as scheduled meetings with interest groups.

Technology opens up the possibility of virtual versions of all of these examples, though I still think there is no substitute for face to face exchanges. Taking politicians and public servants into the communities they serve is not only useful for them, but also for the public to help gain an understanding of the difficult choices and compromises that are required in government.

For the future of our democracy I think we need to give some thought to the way we do our politics, and ensure that it is a process that people feel they want to engage with, and that the engagement is meaningful and worthwhile. 

Phil Lewin

August 13th, 2008

The news of the passing of Phil Lewin is a terrible shock and tragedy.  My heart goes out to his wife, children and family, including his Mum. Phil was an incredibly talented man.  A Rhodes Scholar, a respected diplomat, and a well informed business advocate and lobbyist.  

I spoke with Phil earlier this year about the possibility of him entering politics. He felt the time was not right for him, but I walked away from our discussion knowing that he believed passionately in New Zealand, and I am quite sure would have made a huge contribution on the political stage, if he had eventually chosen that path.

Rest in Peace.

Gap between rich and poor closes

August 12th, 2008

The Social Report  shows that the gap between rich and poor is narrowing.  The full report will be released on 28 August, but according to the Minister the key findings include

  • reduction in income inequality between highest and lowest earners
  • improvement in a range of social indicators for Maori
  • improvements in health and life expectancy.

Programmes like Working For Families, and the big investments in health and education are bearing fruit.  This is great news on the day that we celebrate 70 years since the passing of the Social Security Act.  What that Act put into law was the notion that a caring  society is one that looks after people from the cradle to the grave. As the PM said today

This Labour-led Government, like its forebears, remains committed to ensuring that every New Zealander has a right to a reasonable standard of living, and believes that the community as a whole needs to care for its members.  

back to the future

August 11th, 2008

The much anticipated National welfare policy is really a back to the future exercise, designed to appeal to beneficiary bashing sentiment without actually offering much that is new.  Ruth Dyson covers it off pretty well here. Labour has done a huge amount to lift the living standards of New Zealand families, and there is still more to do.  We need to put the well being of children at the centre of our approaches, and National’s punitive plans will not do that.   Gordon Campbell hits the nail on the head on that score 

This will do nothing to lift children out of poverty and in fact, could well worsen the financial hardship faced by such families 

A fair and inclusive New Zealand needs to ensure that those who are most vulnerable are supported and encouraged, not demonised.




Authorised by Grant Robertson,
160 Willis St, Wellington.

Paid for by Labour Party members and supporters.