Archive for December, 2010

Summer Sport: Black Caps Situation Normal

December 31st, 2010

Ross Taylor, it seems, is bemused.  Welcome to the club Rosco, most of us have been for years when it comes to the Black Caps. In-consistency really is the new/old black.  Two solid performances, albeit against a team without several leading (suspended) players, and who looked like they had they had the kind of jet lag you get from a non-stop trip to Mars, is followed by an absolute shocker.

In the smash and grab that is 20/20 a loss will often be magnified, but last night was bad in any book.  We now move to an entirely different form of the game, and we will see if the selectors play any more interesting games with the test team.  Their experiments with this team did not bode well.  Dean Brownlie?  A couple of good knocks for Canterbury and he is in for a look. We won’t see him again is my guess.

I feel for Adam Milne, and I don’t really think a lot was gained by playing him.  20/20 is not the showcase for speed without variation or subtlety.  Don’t get me wrong, he is a great prospect. He is  quick, and at 18 still has a fair bit of filling out to do.  But he needs to be developed at provincial level. Lance Cairns got this earlier this month, only to go onto the selection panel and promptly be part of picking him.

The Black Caps selectors over the last few seasons have been a bit like a summer race-goer, who puts a dollar each way on the outsider on the basis that it would be amazing if it came off, but no harm done if it does not. Except that the harm is to the consistency of the team, and the confidence of the individual.

There have been positives of course.  McGlashan has worked out how to score, Guptill, and Styris have looked good, Nathan McCullum looks in good touch (and surely must go to 50 over World Cup) and his brother and Dan Vettori are still to come back.

But it looks like another summer of bemusement for us all. And secretly, don’t we just love it!

Summer Sport: Its all happening (for now?)

December 29th, 2010

A little like Ken Barlow from Coronation Street or Nigel Roberts on election night, the Channel Nine cricket commentators just seem to have always been there. From the heady beige days to now we have been treated to Richie, Bill, Ian, Tony and their various friends. A wealth of cricketing experience mixed with lashings of extreme patriotism and buckets of hyperbole, they have marked the modern era of cricket. They even spawned their own genre of comedy.

So much has happened on their watch. Coloured clothing, the 30m circle, hot spot/snicko, the near death and extraordinary resuscitation of test cricket, the arrival of 20:20. As Bill Lawry would say, “its all happening”, and it has been for 30 years.

My favourite times were usually when Bill just lost the plot entirely. ” Share Warne’s a legend. He’s a Victorian, I’m a Victorian.” Or when Tony Greig just did not know who to support if England, South Africa or Australia were playing, and instead resorted to not so subtle put downs regarding the other team.

But is it nearly all over? The ugly demise of Australia as a cricketing powerhouse has nearly reached its apex. The fifth test in Sydney will be Ricky Ponting’s last, and the link to the Australia powerhouse team of the 90s and 00s will be over. They will be just like the rest of us. Only still better than us.

So, what of the commentary team? While various attempts have been made to spruce the team up with the arrival of the extra-aggravating Mark Nicholas, Irritating Ian Healy and Tubs Taylor, the core of the team have stuck through. Richie Benaud, showing the good grace and judgement he has always had, has at least announced a retirement. Surely the time has now come for Chappelli, Greigy, Bill and his pigeons to shuffle off.

Apart from anything else their vacuous boosterism of the Australian team has got little basis to cling to any more. I am sure they are told by Channel Nine to do it, to try to keep the audience when all hope is gone. But the wall to wall coverage of cricket in Australia won’t survive a dramatic form slump like this. It will take time to re-build Australian cricket, and in the modern broadcasting era time is as rare a commodity as Bill and Tony agreeing.

So, if this Ashes series is the end for the Channel Nine team as we know it, I have to say I will miss you guys. Richie told it like it was during the underarm incident, and for that he is a hero. The rest of you annoy me so much some times I turn you off, but to be honest you taught me more about cricket than I ever knew. Cheers fellas.

When the USA gets it right

December 28th, 2010

There has been a fair bit of criticism of the USA following the release of the Wikileaks documents. Most of it deserved, and some of it I have even been part of. As I have said before on this blog, my view on the USA has changed a bit over the years. Before I lived there as a diplomat I had a pretty jaundiced view of the USA as a country. Living there made me realise that like all places it has some amazing people, places and ways of doing things and some bizarre and awful ones too. The Bush era certainly presented lots of the latter category. I still strongly oppose the war-mongering of that era and many of the actions taken in the name of the USA.

But there are times when the USA gets it right and when individuals stand up for ideals in important ways. One of those is the recent removal of the ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’ policy on gays in the military. This was a messy compromise from another era, which has now been rectifiied. I am certainly no supporter of all the actions of the US military, but this piece of discrimination had no place in the modern world.

Barack Obama’s speech at the signing of the legislation to remove the policy is one of his great speeches in my view.

Finally, I want to speak directly to the gay men and women currently serving in our military. For a long time your service has demanded a particular kind of sacrifice. You’ve been asked to carry the added burden of secrecy and isolation. And all the while, you’ve put your lives on the line for the freedoms and privileges of citizenship that are not fully granted to you.

You’re not the first to have carried this burden, for while today marks the end of a particular struggle that has lasted almost two decades, this is a moment more than two centuries in the making.

There will never be a full accounting of the heroism demonstrated by gay Americans in service to this country; their service has been obscured in history. It’s been lost to prejudices that have waned in our own lifetimes. But at every turn, every crossroads in our past, we know gay Americans fought just as hard, gave just as much to protect this nation and the ideals for which it stands.

The full speech is well worth a watch.

Bill English and PEDA- Misleading the House

December 24th, 2010

Bill English will be mighty glad that Parliament is not sitting today as Derek Cheng’s story in the New Zealand Herald today paints an ugly picture of the way the decision was made to fund the Pacific Economic Development Agency. As Derek says

The trail of emails suggest Mr English approved the money without telling the Ministry of Pacific Island Affairs or the Treasury.

In essence it was a complete by-passing of the proper process for Budget decisions. No cabinet paper, no scruitiny from officials. It was the kind of thing the Minister of Finance would never stand for from another Minister.

The person who does come out of the episode with credit is Pacific Island Affairs Chief Executive Colin Tukuitonga. He was prepared to raise concerns about PEDA’s lack of suitability and the weakness of what they were proposing. It is his Ministry that has now done the work to run the tender process, and PEDA has missed out.

There are many questions for Bill English to answer as to why he did this, what his links were with the people involved. He showed little interest in answering those sort of questions in Parliament earlier this year. He did give one interesting answer that we will follow up next year to an oral question from Phil Goff

Hon Phil Goff: Why does the Minister not simply come clean and acknowledge that he, rather than Mrs te Heuheu, negotiated this deal, and that it was done without the normal standards of transparency, accountability, and due diligence that should have been followed before he included the commitment to a specific untested agency in the Budget?

Hon BILL ENGLISH: Because that is simply not correct.

Oh really…..

Taking cynical politics as far as they can go

December 23rd, 2010

I accept that dumping “difficult” information in the week after Parliament shuts and immediately before Christmas has been done by many Governments, but the behaviour by the National government this year has been so cynical it is gob-smacking. We have had

- the release of the Hobbit emails
- the first steps towards privatisation of ACC
- the shutting down of TVNZ6
- sale of Whirinaki power plant

- and now the announcement this morning that the $4.8 million that the government gave to the Pacific Economic Development Agency (PEDA) without any tender process in the Budget has now been allocated to several other providers, with PEDA missing out.

The first thing to say is to congratulate my colleague Sua William Sio, other MPs and members of the Pacific community who doggedly pursued this case. It was an outrageous breach of good governance and convention to allocate the money to PEDA in the first place. This was an organisation with no track record, let alone the suggestion of links to National MPs.

The backdown that followed was the right thing to do, even if it took a long time. But there can be no doubting that the timing of the announcement today is deliberate to limit comment on the initial decision and the indictment on the National government that after a proper process PEDA did not get any of the money.

And we politicians wonder why many of the public don’t have faith or trust in us.  Disgraceful.




Authorised by Grant Robertson,
160 Willis St, Wellington.

Paid for by Labour Party members and supporters.